critics reviews for baz lurhmans the good gatsby are merely not that nice. its the fourth big screen adaptation of f. scott fitzgeralds 1925 novel, that follows would-be writer nick carraway as hes drawn into jay gatsbys lavish circle, changing into a witness to actually obsession and tragedy. the most recent version stars leonardo dicaprio, tobey maguire, carey mulligan, isla fisher, joel edgerton and jason clarke.
within the good gatsby : director baz luhrmann, wife and collaborator catherine martin talk films circus-like vision
an estimated $100 million was poured straight into the latest eye-sight, and though critics have praised dicaprios performance, several reviewers assume the movie fails to actually grasp the last word eye-sight of one's book. u. s. news and world report notes the film falls short attempting to actually serve each the fitzgerald original and its filmmakers aesthetic.
the new york times points out that its less a standard movie adaptation when compared to a splashy, trashy opera, a wayward, lavishly theatrical celebration of one's emotional and material extravagance that fitzgerald surveyed with fascinated ambivalence.
still, dicaprio has actually been described as persuasive and magnificent in role clearly as the mysterious millionaire.
the very first film adaptation of the good gatsby came in 1926 currently being a silent movie. it really has since been lost, and then a trailer remains. in 1946, another feature came out, starring alan ladd, betty field, and shelley winters. and in 1976, sam waterston took upon the role of carraway, with mia farrow as daisy buchanan and robert redford as gatsby.
the good gatsby of 2013 possesses a 46 p.c rating on film aggregator website, rotten tomatoes. scan on to discover what a few of one's prime critics have to actually say about it :
joe morgenstern of one's wall street journal : this dreadful film even derogates the artistry of fitzgerald, who wrote the good gatsby whereas living on long island and in europe. because we are part of a deviation direct from book that amounts to the calumny against literary history, nick, the authors surrogate, is discovered because we are part of a psychiatric hospital where, as an aging alcoholic, he struggles to actually comprehend the vanished figure for the center of one's long-ago story, and finally completes his treatment by writing the novel. its literature as therapy, and gatsby as rosebud.
rafer guzman of newsday gave it 3 out of every 4 stars, noting : the fourth adaptation of one's fitzgerald novel scores a few hits and wild misses, however dicaprio nails the bulls-eye. he's gatsby, though gatsby has nevertheless to remain made.
todd mccarthy of one's hollywood reporter : the solid is first-rate, the ambiance and story supply a live of intoxication and, most importantly, the core thematic considerations pertaining towards the american dream, self-reinvention and love lost, regained and lost once more are tenaciously addressed.
ann hornaday of one's washington post : despite timely relevance, enduring truths and luhrmanns earnest efforts to actually make the good gatsby jump off of the screen, he -- so we -- finally cant help however fail to actually grasp it.
david edelstein of recent york magazine : one of the best factor about baz luhrmanns much-anticipated/much-dreaded the good gatsby is, for all those its computer-generated whoosh and overbroad acting, it's unmistakably f. scott fitzgeralds the good gatsby. that will be no small deal.
connie ogle of one's miami herald : baz luhrmanns the good gatsby may be a failure that must have a minimum of been a magnificent mistake, a risky endeavor that showed a daring intent even when its brash eye-sight didnt quite succeed. instead, the movie leaves you cold and weary and vaguely disgusted, like youve only spent a night of debauchery at gatsbys mansion, and currently the sun is up, and its time to actually fish the cigarette butts and champagne bottles out of every the pool.
mike bertha of one's philadelphia inquirer : here i'm, disappointed with luhrmanns film, partly as a result of i refused to actually quell my very own anticipation. however, too, as a result of the most recent interpretation of gatsby appeared to actually distort the values fans of one's story hold therefore dearly.
source : http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-207_162-57583889/the-great-gatsby-reviews-are-not-so-great/
No comments:
Post a Comment